Loading... 
Old Time Candy
Old Time Candy, Old Fashioned Candy, Old Fashion Nostalgic Candy
Old time candy is a great gift for all occasions. We offer nostalgic candy that you ate as a child from the 1950's, 60's and 70's. Atomic Fireball, Beeman's gum, Bubble Gum Cigars and Cigarettes, Bit o' Honey, Candy buttons,Necklaces, Peanut Chews, Circus Peanuts, Cotton Candy, Caramel Vanilla and more. Our candy store is packed with your favorite retro candy from when you were a kid. Old time candy makes a unique gift!
Our entire selection of old time candy is listed below. If you have any questions about our old time candy selections, visit our FAQ section or contact us for more information. Our friendly staff will be happy to answer any questions you may have.
-
Anise Bears
(5 Pounds)$11.90 ($2.38/lb.) -
Atomic Fireballs
(6 Pounds)$22.20 ($3.70/lb.) -
Atomic Fireballs 150ct Jar
(150 Count)$15.00 ($0.10 ea.)
-
Baby Ruth Bar-24 Count
(24 Count)$26.88 ($1.12 ea.) -
Baby Ruth Miniatures
(6.5 Pounds)$40.24 ($6.20/lb.) -
BB Bats 100ct.
(100 Count)$15.80 ($0.16 ea.)
-
Beechies Peppermint Gum 2pc. 100ct.
(100 Count)$13.68 ($0.14 ea.) -
Beechies Spearmint Gum 2pc. 100ct.
(100 Count)$13.68 ($0.14 ea.) -
Bit O Honey 24ct.
(24 Count)$26.88 ($1.12 ea.)
-
Black Cow 24ct.
(24 Count)$20.40 ($0.85 ea.) -
Bob's Sweet Stripe Soft Mint Candy 160ct.
(160 Count)$9.34 ($0.06 ea.) -
Bonomo 1.5oz. Banana
(24 Count)$27.84 ($1.16 ea.)
-
Bonomo 1.5oz. Chocolate
(24 Count)$27.84 ($1.16 ea.) -
Bonomo 1.5oz. Strawberry
(24 Count)$27.84 ($1.16 ea.) -
Bonomo 1.5oz. Vanilla
(24 Count)$27.84 ($1.16 ea.)
-
Bonomo Turkish Taffy 216pc. Changemaker Assorted Bite Size
(216 Count)$32.40 ($0.15 ea.) -
Bottle Caps Roll 24ct.
(24 Count)$26.88 ($1.12 ea.) -
Boyer Mallo Cup 24ct.
(24 Count)$26.88 ($1.12 ea.)
-
Bubble Gum Cigarettes
(24 Count)$23.20 ($0.97 ea.) -
Butterfinger 3.5oz. Movie Theater Box
(6 Count)$9.60 ($1.60 ea.) -
Butterfinger Bars-36 Count
(36 Count)$41.76 ($1.16 ea.)
-
Butterfinger Miniatures Bulk
(6.5 Pounds)$40.24 ($6.20/lb.) -
Butterscotch Discs
(6.3 Pounds)$15.25 ($2.43/lb.) -
C. Howard Scented Gum 24ct.
(24 Count)$19.32 ($0.81 ea.)